The Problems With SIM Trading

Simulator trading—also known as paper trading—is wildly overrated. I regularly tell people they should get off the sim as quickly as possible. It creates a false sense of safety that actually works against a trader’s development.

No one trades the same way on a simulator as they do with real money.

The theory behind simulator trading sounds reasonable: learn to trade without risk, prove you can be profitable, then go live with confidence. If you made money on the sim, you should be able to make money in the real market by doing the exact same thing.

That assumption is deeply flawed.

The Boxing Ring Problem

I compare this to learning a physical sport. You can study boxing technique, footwork, and strategy for years—but until you step into a ring and get hit, you don’t truly understand what fighting is.

Punching bags don’t hit back. Markets do.

Simulator trading removes the single most important variable in trading: real consequences.

What SIM Trading Is Actually Good For

A simulator does have value—but it’s limited.

You should use it briefly to:

• Learn your trading platform
• Avoid mouse errors and order entry mistakes
• Practice placing, adjusting, and canceling orders
• Get used to watching the market all day

Once you can execute trades quickly and understand what you’re seeing on the screen, you should go live.

For most people, this takes a few weeks—maybe a month at most.

You Don’t Manage Trades the Same Way

What traders fail to understand is that you do not manage winners or losers the same way when real money is on the line.

It’s easy to say, “I would have done this” or “I would have held that” when nothing is at stake. It’s very different when each tick is costing you real dollars, your heart rate is elevated, and adrenaline is flooding your system.

Let’s look at two common examples.

Example A: Losing Trades

SIM Trading

You think you see a setup and enter with a four-tick stop. Price moves against you. You don’t exit. It goes five ticks against you, then back to four, then back to breakeven, and eventually turns into a winner.

You tell yourself: I was early, but I read it right.

Live Trading

You take the same trade and exit immediately at a four-tick loss because you know that ignoring it can quickly turn into an eight-tick loss.

Or:

• You scratch it early for a two-tick loss
• Re-enter lower when it stabilizes
• Or skip the trade entirely because it’s not that great
• Or don’t take it because you’re already up money and want to protect your day

Because you know that if you give back your profits, you’re probably glued to the screen for the next four hours trying to fix it.

The Result

On the sim, you were rewarded for bad behavior. In real life, that habit eventually wipes you out.

Real money teaches risk aversion fast—because every dollar lost is a dollar you could have spent on something better than staring at flashing numbers.

Example B: Winning Trades

SIM Trading

You’re up six ticks with a ten-tick target. Momentum stalls, but you sit through thirty minutes of chop as your unrealized profit repeatedly drops to three ticks. Eventually, price drifts higher and hits the target.

You made ten ticks. You were “right.”

Live Trading

You take the six ticks.

You recognize that risking six to maybe make four more—especially when momentum has clearly stalled—is a bad trade. You book the profit and move on.

Or, if you do try to hold, you may end up taking three ticks on the first pullback because you don’t want to watch it retrace to breakeven.

The Result

On paper, ten ticks. In reality, six—or sometimes three. And that’s normal.

Simulators Can Be Gamed

Another major issue is that simulators often provide unrealistic fills.

Traders convince themselves they can scalp the bid and offer all day—when in live markets, they would never receive most of those fills. Slippage, queue position, and speed matter, and simulators don’t replicate that well.

Why Prop Firms Get This Wrong

Many prop firms require traders to hit performance benchmarks on a simulator before going live.

This is a terrible idea.

I know this from personal experience and from countless emails I’ve received over the years.

At the firm where I worked, we were on the simulator for three days. Then we were given a one-lot, a daily loss limit, and told to trade.

Management understood something important: you can’t learn without taking some hits.

Every new trader hit their loss limit on days one and two. Every single one. That’s how it works.

By day three, some traders began learning the most important lesson of all: stop trading when you don’t know what’s happening.

That lesson alone is priceless.

A Trader’s Wake-Up Call

Here’s an email I once received from a trader whose firm used sim performance as a gatekeeper:

“I finally went live today and it was a baptism by fire. I was completely unprepared for how different live trading feels. I was stopped out by 8:30am.

The fills and slippage shocked me. Stops didn’t behave the way they did on the sim, and everything felt faster.

For the past 2.5 months on the simulator, I had only five losing days—each no more than six ticks. My winners were consistently ten ticks or more.

Wow. My head hurts.”

The rest of his week looked similar. Which is normal.

He had been on the simulator far longer than those 2.5 months. Those were just the months where he finally hit the firm’s required metrics.

That’s how well sim results translated to real trading.

Live Trading Accelerates Learning

You’ll learn more in five days of live trading than in five months on a simulator.

Keeping someone on a sim for three to six months delays the inevitable. Once they go live, the real learning still hasn’t begun—and most traders won’t turn the corner for six to twelve months after that.

So why delay the process?

At my firm, some traders were down over $30,000 before they became consistently profitable. That’s reality. You can’t make it in this business without risking something.

Final Advice

If you run a prop firm, you may want to rethink how you evaluate new traders.

If you’re an individual trader looking to progress faster:

• Get off the simulator
• Trade small
• Respect your loss limits
• Don’t overtrade
• Be selective
• Build correct habits early

Don’t be reckless—but don’t hide behind fake confidence from sim results.

Paper trading is a tool. Real trading is the teacher.

Here are some additional articles about futures traders and order flow you will enjoy:

The Best Futures Funding Programs (more details below):

• Apex Trader Funding – #1 recommended firm. Have up to 20 accounts low cost
• Take Profit Trader – Great dashboard, fast payouts (treasuries allowed)
• My Funded Futures – Fastest payouts of any firm available, large selection of account types
• DayTraders – Straight to Funded, Static and Trailing DD available
• The Futures Desk – Build your own evaluation! (treasuries allowed)
• TradeDay – Move to full live account quickly (treasuries allowed)

Be Notified Of New Trader Evaluation Promotions

Submit your email if you want to be notified of new trader evaluation promotions. I never spam nor sell anything. Usually 2-3 emails a month are sent with the latest deals.

Risk Disclosure:

Futures and forex trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. An investor could potentially lose all or more than the initial investment. Risk capital is money that can be lost without jeopardizing ones’ financial security or life style. Only risk capital should be used for trading and only those with sufficient risk capital should consider trading. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results.

Hypothetical Performance Disclosure: 

Hypothetical performance results have many inherent limitations, some of which are described below. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those shown; in fact, there are frequently sharp differences between hypothetical performance results and the actual results subsequently achieved by any particular trading program. One of the limitations of hypothetical performance results is that they are generally prepared with the benefit of hindsight.

In addition, hypothetical trading does not involve financial risk, and no hypothetical trading record can completely account for the impact of financial risk of actual trading. for example, the ability to withstand losses or to adhere to a particular trading program in spite of trading losses are material points which can also adversely affect actual trading results. There are numerous other factors related to the markets in general or to the implementation of any specific trading program which cannot be fully accounted for in the preparation of hypothetical performance results and all which can adversely affect trading results.

You can read more here: Risk Disclosure

Affiliate Disclosure:

The external links on my site and in my video descriptions to trader evaluation companies and software companies are primarily affiliate links. I earn a commission from these companies on any sale made from people visiting these links. That said, I only recommend companies and software I personally use and actually do recommend. Believe me, I turn down a lot of companies who approach me. You can read my full Affiliate Disclosure here.

Additional Disclosure:

The content provided is for informational purposes only. I do my best to keep the content current and accurate by updating it frequently. Sometimes the actual data, rules, requirements and other can differ from what’s stated on our website. CanadianFuturesTrader.ca is an independent website. You should always consult the rules, faqs, knowledge base and support of any of the websites and companies we link to or talk about on our site. The information on their site will always be what ultimately dictates the current rules of their program, software or other. While we are independent, we may be compensated for advertisements, sponsored products, or when you click on a link on our website. The contributors and authors are not registered or certified financial advisors. You should consult a financial professional before making any financial decisions.